Home » Resources » Case Study: Securing a First CFO to Support Organizational Growth
November 12, 2026
A growing economic development organization faced an important turning point in its financial leadership. After years of operating with a Controller-led finance function, the organization recognized that its expanding responsibilities, increased financial complexity, and evolving stakeholder expectations required a more strategic approach to financial management.
The organization engaged Smith + Howard to recruit its first Chief Financial Officer (CFO). By combining Executive Search + Recruiting and fractional Finance + Accounting expertise, the engagement provided continuity during the leadership transition while identifying an executive capable of strengthening financial oversight and connecting organizational investment to measurable outcomes.
Rapid organizational growth and increasing expectations for financial accountability created the need for executive-level leadership beyond the organization’s existing Controller-led structure.
For years, the organization’s finance function had been managed by a Controller rather than a dedicated CFO. Leadership had previously considered establishing a more senior finance position but ultimately maintained the existing structure.
As the organization continued to grow, that model became increasingly difficult to sustain. A larger operating budget, heightened scrutiny of funding, and more sophisticated Board expectations created new demands for financial reporting, strategic planning, and organizational accountability.
The organization needed a CFO who could do more than oversee accounting operations. The incoming executive would be expected to provide strategic financial direction, strengthen reporting capabilities, and help leadership evaluate the effectiveness of its investments.
Demonstrating return on investment was a central priority. As an organization focused on economic development, leadership needed greater visibility into how financial resources translated into measurable economic outcomes. The CFO would play a critical role in communicating those results to the Board, funders, and other stakeholders.
Smith + Howard combined experienced fractional finance leadership with a targeted executive search, addressing immediate operational needs while identifying the right leader for the organization’s next stage of growth.
While the executive search was underway, a fractional finance leader stepped in to support the organization’s existing finance function. The engagement included an assessment of financial operations and targeted clean-up work to address immediate priorities.
The fractional leader also provided technical knowledge and firsthand insight into the organization’s financial structure, helping maintain continuity throughout the transition.
This coordinated approach gave the executive search team a deeper understanding of the organization’s financial environment, operational challenges, and leadership requirements while allowing the organization to continue addressing important financial priorities.
The executive search focused on identifying a finance leader who could bring both technical expertise and a broader strategic perspective to the organization.
Beyond traditional financial management experience, the ideal candidate needed to understand how to connect financial investment with measurable organizational impact. Experience demonstrating return on investment within a complex financial environment was particularly important.
Drawing on a professional network cultivated over many years, the Smith + Howard Search team identified a candidate whose previous experience closely aligned with these requirements.
The relationship had originated through a professional referral several years earlier and had been maintained over time. Familiarity with the candidate’s background, including relevant experience addressing financial accountability and ROI challenges, helped the team recognize a strong potential fit for the position.
Established relationships and trusted referrals provided additional confidence in the candidate’s qualifications and alignment with the organization’s needs.
The engagement successfully filled the organization’s first CFO position while providing financial leadership and operational continuity throughout the executive search process.
As organizations grow, financial leadership must evolve alongside operational complexity, stakeholder expectations, and the need for greater accountability.
For organizations establishing executive-level financial leadership for the first time, a successful transition requires both continuity and a clear understanding of future needs. By combining experienced fractional finance support with targeted executive search capabilities, Smith + Howard helped a growing economic development organization navigate a critical leadership transition and secure a CFO whose experience aligned with its long-term priorities.
Director, Executive Search + Recruiting
Amanda Sower is a Director in Smith + Howard’s Executive Search practice, specializing in C-suite and senior leadership searches for private equity, professional services, and mission-driven organizations. She partners with boards, CEOs, and investors to identify leadership talent aligned with their business objectives and long-term growth strategies.
If you have any questions and would like to connect with a team member please call 404-874-6244 or contact an advisor below.
Subscribe to our newsletters to get inside access to timely news, trends and insights from Smith + Howard.